The room is suddenly quiet. The monitors have stopped beeping, the code team has dispersed, and the patient has been stabilized or transferred. But for the nurse standing at the bedside, the room is still spinning. Whether it was a medication calculation or titration error, a missed change in vital signs, or a procedural complication, the realization hits like a physical blow: I made a mistake, oh my God!
While our primary focus in healthcare is always the patient (the first victim), there is a silent, secondary trauma that occurs in the aftermath of a clinical error. This is called the Second Victim Phenomenon. If the nursing retention crisis and patient safety can be solved, we must start talking about the emotional wreckage left behind when healers fail.
Who cares for the carer when things go wrong?
Some victims lose their license, and some, their confidence. Let’s explore why nurses suffer and what can be done to address the Second Victim Phenomenon.
The Perfectionism Trap: Why Nurses Suffer More
Nurses are conditioned from the first day of clinicals to strive for 100% accuracy. We operate within a culture that often equates clinical errors with personal incompetence. When something goes wrong, the internal monologue is devastating: “I am a bad nurse. I am dangerous. I don’t belong in this profession.”
This perfectionism trap creates some kind of “shame spiral.” Because we feel our integrity has been compromised, we often isolate ourselves. We fear the judgment of our peers and the disciplinary actions of management, which only deepens the psychological trauma and contributes to long-term nursing burnout.
READ ALSO: Telehealth for Nurses: How Nurses Are Adapting to Virtual Care
The Six Stages of the Second Victim Journey
Research by Dr Susan Scott identifies a predictable path that nurses travel after a traumatic clinical event.
Understanding these stages can help you (or a colleague) realize that your feelings are a normal reaction to an abnormal situation:
- Chaos and Accident Response: The immediate “fight or flight” moment where you realize something is wrong and try to stabilize the patient while managing your own rising panic.
- Intrusive Reflections: The “What If” stage. You replay the event on a loop, unable to sleep, wondering how you missed a detail that seems so obvious in hindsight.
- Restoring Personal Integrity: This is the identity crisis. You wonder if your colleagues will ever trust you again and if you can ever trust yourself.
- Enduring the Inquisition: Navigating the formal side; incident reports, management meetings, and Root Cause Analysis. This stage often feels like being “put on trial.”
- Obtaining Emotional First Aid: Seeking support. Unfortunately, many nurses find that their workplace lacks a formal system for this, leaving them to suffer in silence.
- Moving On: The final stage results in one of three outcomes: thriving (learning and growing), surviving (continuing to work but carrying the weight), or dropping out (leaving the unit or the profession entirely).
Moving from “Blame Culture” to “Just Culture”
For decades, the healthcare response to error was to find a person to blame. However, modern safety science tells us that errors are rarely the fault of one person. Usually, they are the result of understaffing, poor labelling, fatigue, or faulty equipment, which later results in Nursing Burnout and Moral Injury.
A Just Culture recognizes that human error is inevitable, but reckless behaviour is not. When hospitals support the “second victim,” they encourage honest reporting. When nurses feel safe enough to admit a mistake without being destroyed emotionally, the entire system learns how to prevent that mistake from happening again.
How to Heal: Advice for the Second Victim
If you are currently struggling with the weight of a clinical error, remember these three things:
- You are not your mistake: One moment in time does not erase the thousands of lives you have touched and the shifts you have worked with excellence.
- Seek Peer Support: Speak to a trusted colleague. You will likely find that the most experienced nurses on your unit have their own stories of errors and “near misses.”
- Advocate for Change: Use the experience to look at the system. Was the pump confusing? Was the handoff report incomplete? Turning your pain into a process improvement can be a powerful form of healing.
Conclusion: Understanding the Second Victim Phenomenon in the Nursing Profession
Nursing is an act of extreme vulnerability. We step into the lives of strangers on their worst days and promise to keep them safe. When that promise is broken, even by accident, the wound goes deep.
It is time to stop the silence. By recognizing the Second Victim Phenomenon, we can build a more resilient workforce and a safer healthcare system. We cannot expect nurses to provide compassionate care to patients if we do not provide compassionate care to our nurses when they are hurting.
I ask again: Who cares for the carer when things go wrong? Let me know in the comments box.
